top of page

Property & Sales Taxes Are Among Ohio's Highest

What the Passage of Two Levies Will Cost West Shore Homeowners

Average West Shore homeowner with a $350,000 home will pay about $582 more per year.

Cuyahoga County voters approved two separate property tax levies on the Nov 2026 ballot.  The requests are from the Health and Human Services and the Board of Developmental Disabilities. 

Roads & Bridges

Cuyahoga County 8% Sales Tax is Among Highest in Ohio

Council Voted to Extend 40-Year Sales Tax Extension Without Voter Approval
Recent Sales Tax Collections Are Over $400 Million & Represent 23% of Total Operating Revenue

Cuyahoga County’s 8.0% sales tax is made up of Ohio’s statewide base rate: 5.75% and a local “piggyback” sales tax added by the county.  The combined rate is one of the highest in Ohio, just below Franklin County’s 8.25% rate. It is substantially higher than nearby counties, which is a disincentive for shoppers and new homeowners.

 

In 2007, a 0.25% sales tax was approved for 20 years by the voters. Rather than let the sales tax expire in 2027, County Executive Ronayne proposed that council approve extending the existing 0.25% sales tax for 40 years. Instead of submitting the tax to a public vote, County Council narrowly approved the extension with a 6-5 vote after defeating several amendments. County Council Representative Kelly provided the deciding vote for a 40-year extension of a sales tax passed without voter approval.

​

Northeast Ohio sales tax rates
Map of sales tax rates in Ohio by county
Cuyahoga County sales tax revenue
For more information, read the PDF.

Cuyahoga County Property Tax Burden is Among Highest in Ohio

Cuyahoga Effective Rate At 2.085%, Highest of Major Ohio Counties
Recent Appraisal impacted Seniors, Increased Valuation Challenges & Burdened County Manpower

The average effective property tax rate (Property Taxes/ Housing Value) in Cuyahoga is approximately 2.085%, which is the highest among several major counties in the state. This rate is significantly above the national average, contributing to a substantial tax burden for residents. The effective rate may vary by community and school district. The high rate is a significant negative factor affecting Cuyahoga County's economic development appeal.

Median House Value ($183,200)
X Effective Rate (2.085%) = Median Tax Burden ($3,819)

The recent appraisal, combined with Cuyahoga's high effective rates, led to significant increases in the amount of taxes to be paid each year. The increase led to many challenges and delinquencies as seniors and others on fixed incomes struggled to pay the increases.

Cuyahoga Property Tax Revenue Ranking in Ohio
Cuyahoga Appraisal Changes by City
Cuyahgoa County Property Tax Revenue
For more information, read the PDF.

Understanding Property Taxes

Property taxes are a major political issue in 2026. The report is a summary of how property taxes are calculated with specific local examples. It reviews property taxes across five West Shore communities in Cuyahoga County: Bay Village, Fairview Park, North Olmsted, Rocky River, and Westlake.

Property Taxes of Local Leaders
  • Calculation: Assessed value = 35% of market value, times local millage, then adjusted for HB 920, rollbacks, and credits. HB 920 limits increases from rising valuations but doesn't freeze bills.

  • Distribution: Schools 48–58%, county 18–26%, municipalities 15–19%.

  • Rates: Effective rates of 2.38% (Bay Village, Fairview Park, North Olmsted), 1.93% (Rocky River), 1.71% (Westlake) — equal to 5.6%–7.2% of median income.

  • Reform: A major 2026 issue, split between resident relief and state structural change, with consensus on helping seniors and fixed-income residents. Additional concrete proposals need to be developed and analyzed.

Property Taxes for Different Home Values

Understanding Property Tax Burdens in the West Shore Communities

A Non-technical Review Provides A Basis for Evaluating Reform Proposals

Property taxes are a major political issue in 2026. The report is a summary of how property taxes are calculated with specific local examples. It reviews property taxes across five West Shore communities in Cuyahoga County: Bay Village, Fairview Park, North Olmsted, Rocky River, and Westlake.

How taxes are calculated: Bills depend on property value, local tax rates, and HB 920 credits. Assessed value equals 35% of market value, with millage applied to that figure and further adjustments from HB 920, rollbacks, and credits. HB 920 dampens increases from rising valuations but doesn't freeze bills entirely. A $350,000 home has an assessed value of about $122,500; a 3.0-mill levy would generate roughly $367.50 before adjustments.

Where the money goes: Schools take the largest share at 48–58%, followed by the county at 18–26% and municipalities at 15–19%.

Local rates: Effective rates run about 2.38% in Bay Village, Fairview Park, and North Olmsted, 1.93% in Rocky River, and 1.71% in Westlake. Tax burdens equal roughly 5.6–7.2% of median household income.

Reform outlook: Proposals are split between direct resident relief and broader state-level structural change. Consensus centers on easing burdens for seniors and fixed-income residents, addressing payment scheduling and delinquencies, and softening reappraisal spikes. 

Property Taxes for Community Leaders
Where Property Taxes Go
For more information, read the PDF.

Ohio's "Historic" Property Tax Relief Skipped the West Shore

Legislature Addressed Some Problems, But Solutions Had Minimal Effect on West Shore Taxpayers

In December 2025, Ohio enacted a five-bill property tax package that took effect in March 2026. Sponsors called it "$3 billion in historic property tax relief."

Why the West Shore Didn't Benefit. Unfortunately, West Shore homeowners didn't see many benefits. The centerpiece bill, HB 186, caps revenue growth only for school districts sitting at Ohio's 20-mill floor. Just five districts in all of Cuyahoga County qualified for the new Inflation Cap Credit — and none of the five West Shore districts were eligible. Bay Village, Fairview Park, Rocky River, and Westlake got no relief from the provision that generated the headlines.

What Didn't Change. The 2024 reappraisal remains fully in place, after raising countywide residential values an average of 32% — including 25%+ in Bay Village, 25.9% in Fairview Park, and 25.4% in Rocky River. Long-term homeowners absorbed that increase and will keep paying on it. One in five West Shore residents is 65 or older (roughly 24% in Rocky River and Westlake), the group most exposed to a valuation-driven tax. And people are already falling behind: countywide past-due property tax balances ran $60.6 million above the prior year as of mid-2025.

Abolition Issues. A citizen initiative to eliminate property taxes is gathering signatures and may reach the ballot. The frustration is legitimate — but the math is unforgiving. Property taxes supply Cuyahoga County roughly $435 million in revenue, about 25% of total revenue, and fund 48–58% of West Shore school budgets. The Governor's Office of Budget and Management estimates full replacement would require a statewide income tax of 11–15% or a sales tax of 15–18%. The Tax Foundation finds suburban communities could see a net tax increase under either approach, because urban areas currently carry heavier property tax burdens. The likely result isn't a West Shore tax cut. It may be a tax shift — from Cleveland onto Bay Village, Rocky River, and Westlake.

What we should be fighting for instead: A practical first step is targeted, income-based relief that reaches the seniors and long-term homeowners actually being squeezed — not blanket changes that pass us by or quietly raise our bills. The targeted relief should provide time to evaluate more extensive changes in the property tax system and the impact of changes on government and school funding. One change that should be explored that would improve transparency and understanding of the responsibility for cost is separating the current property tax bill into a school property tax bill and a government services property tax bill.

Roads & Bridges
For more information, read the PDF.
bottom of page